 鲜花( 1)  鸡蛋( 0)
|

楼主 |
发表于 2006-4-19 15:45
|
显示全部楼层
Can “knowledge” be learned?
9 V0 W- }+ _- p4 W& z/ F; t7 W请看下面这句话错在什么地方?
% R7 |, e; r, [7 YAs we have learned a lot of knowledge from our teachers, we always think of them when we achieve something. (我们从老师那里学到了很多知识,所以每当我们有所成就时总是想到他们。)9 J2 _6 |+ v- p, n2 w- y2 K0 E( e
在英语实践中常有这种情况:似乎大家都这么说就是对的,实际则不然。上面这句就是个典型的例子。“学知识”这种说法在汉语里经常听到,译成英语就成了learn knowledge。可是在英语里,knowledge不和learn搭配,我们只能用有“得到”意思的动词来搭配,如:get,gain,acquire,也可用表示“扩大”和其他意思的动词,如broaden,enrich,widen,extend,improve等等。因此,这一句的前半句可以改为:As we’ve broadened our knowledge by learning from our teachers,或者干脆说As we’ve learned a lot from our teachers.
" x+ x9 \5 b; d( K! j0 _/ u- lSit well引起的思考
- b* C+ M0 C* y L# Z2 X2 M我不止一次听到中学老师上课时对学生说“Sit well!”(坐好!”)从语言角度谈,如果一个学生坐的姿势不好,那应该说“Sit straight!”同样,“站好!”也就是“Stand straight!”而不是“Stand well!”而深一步从文化上看,它表明不同国家有着不同的教育习俗。来自西方国家的老师或教育家参观我们的学校时,惊奇地发现有的40学生多分钟内手一直放在背后,挺着胸听课,认为如此要求学生过于苛刻,在西方国家,小学生、甚至低年级中学生的课桌并不安排排列,有的围成方形,有的围成一圈,以达到不仅老师与学生,而且学生与学生间交流的目的。就学生姿势而言,只要不是躺着,或靠在别人身上,并不要求坐直。如果学生身体活动过多,或相互间交流过于频繁,超出了课堂活动所允许的范围,老师一般只是说“Please pay attention to…”或“Attention ,please”或“May I have your attention”,所以,“Sit well!”是Qinglish,而“Sit straight!”只是在中国教室这一特定条件下可以说的、无误的英语。7 Q9 t3 l/ z1 x
了解中国国情的native speakers毕竟不是多数- [9 I! C& I3 t& o2 E. j1 `
下面三句话意思很好,也没有语法错误,但不能说是好的英语,问题在哪儿呢?
9 x4 X* z" ], S% H# m3 @: j1. Since liberation/1949 great changes have taken place in my hometown.
3 ~0 L8 \3 d5 P2. My sister is a nurse; my brother is a PLA man.
# S; X# Y% K1 n' T. T+ z3. The poor peasants talked about their happy life. They owed it to the leadership of the Chinese Communist Party.(贫农们谈论他们的幸福生活,并把它归功于中国***的领导。)
' F* d& _* n" Y2 e$ u# N& C$ D8 b如果是说给懂英语的中国人听或写给中国人看,问题不大。几乎任何一个懂事的中国人都知道“解放”是指“1949中华人民共和国建立”,但是如果对象是English-speaking people,就可能出现问题,因为不了解中国历史的native speakers是多数。我们说惯了“自解放以来”,来做竖向比较,但许多外国人不明白。难怪有人误解成women’s lib,那就是六十年代西方出现的的women’s liberation movement(妇女解放运动)。最好把since liberation或since 1949写清楚为since the founding of the People’s Republic of China in 1949.
( r/ e+ d" ]8 e# n1 }& |同样,除了在中国逗留过一段时间的外国人之外,很少有人懂得什么是a PLA man。与其说My brother is a PLA man, 不如说My brother is in the army/service,或My brother serves in the army,或My brother is a soldier/an army officer.( ^( Q Z" @0 g( j% B! R
绝大多数English-speaking people不明白poor peasants有着特定的政治含义,“贫农”是个社会阶层。在英语里poor意思是“没钱,吃不饱,没有任何享受”;English-speaking people想“没钱过舒适生活的贫苦农民又怎能过上幸福生活呢?”在这种情况下,最好要有注解,让读者明白poor peasants的殊定含义。
; M' b4 {! y# U/ H% S* jShe learned English through self-study, and she studied English very hard.这话有什么错9 H& \" g$ g7 i+ ?$ O4 F" V
“自习”、“自学英语”、“自学成才”等由“自”组成的汉语译成英语时,初学者能想到前缀self-是好的。由前缀self-构成的词多达六七十个,如:
3 B( ~+ F# C/ Sself-reliance (自力更生)
) t' W8 ]! D8 Vself-service (自我服务)0 z; b* C; i" d0 w. L( K& Q
self-defence (自卫)! A0 A# D; x) E1 ]4 B5 c) k( X
self-important (自高自大的)
) ?* _' {3 e1 a. a/ `. Eself-sufficient (自给自足的)+ o0 u j0 X5 \4 r8 S/ F
self-setermination (自决)$ Z9 W) \% p" s2 ~7 R- ~; ?: E5 F
但是我们常用的self-study尽管English-speaking people能懂,但并不是正确的英语。因此,不宜说She learned English through self-study;应该说When learned English on her own/by herself,或She taught herself English.我们常说的“培养自学能力“相应地可以译为We should cultivate our ability to study independently/on our own.而“自学课本”如译成self-study books也不宜,可以说teacher-yourself books或English self-taught.同样,“自习”应该是individual study。譬如:I’m taking six courses this semester, so I don’t have much time for individual study(这个学期我选了六门课,所以自习时间不多。)9 N8 ?* E2 Q# o! }+ c
这句话里还有一个常见的错误,说study hard当然没有问题,但把“她努力学习英语”说成She studies English hard却不符合英语习惯。要表示出“努力学习”的对象,可以用work hard at something的形式。譬如:She works very hard at English.. |) \9 S6 W4 s% x# [% C$ N; k) a
Learn from somebody的真正含义是什么5 m/ J4 o6 Q& e# T/ V1 k
有人把“我不会学你,因为我不象你有那么多钱”译成I won’t learn from you, as I don’t have as much money as you do.
1 V, w# {: g7 c9 t' ~这是错用learn from的例子。某人得知对方以160元买了条进口领带时说的,表示“我不打算学你”。Learn from是“学习某人的优点、经验、某种技术、知识”或“从某中吸取某种经验、教训”。而“我学你”是指“在某种行为上学你的样子”或“我效法你”的意思。正确的英语是follow one’s example或follow suit。譬如:& j6 U0 E9 W2 n4 U$ }7 i* y: s
Mary decided to help in the housework, and Sherry and Rebecca followed her example. (Mary决定帮忙干家务活,Sherry和Rebecca也跟着效法Mary.)
) I4 g" @! }0 \9 ?! j& e0 w7 |" P L. nWhen one shop began to prolong its business hours all other shops along the same street followed suit. (一家铺开始延长营业时间,沿街所有别的商店也照方抓药。)0 Y; t2 Y$ d" c9 a4 e% Q
依此类推有时会出错4 ~+ }& m' ?3 @$ ?; v
请先读一下下面这段报道:1 m' ?! b! Q! Z; V2 n1 R/ M
Something went wrong with the tap, so I didn’t have any water in the washroom. I went to the nearby housing maintenance station five times to ask for help. It was nearly half a year later that two workers were sent to my house to fix it. (这一段英语摘自<中国日报>,意思是:水龙头出了毛病,厕所里一点水也没有。我跑了五趟附近的房管所求助;半年以后才派两位工人来我家里修理。7 G7 x+ M* D+ ^; D' V
绝大数学生把这段话看来看去觉得没什么毛病;有的把Something went wrong改为There was something wrong;有的把nearby放在station后面,并写成两个字。都没改错,可都没改在点子上。究竟错在哪里呢?我们说half-an hour是地道英语,但不能依此类推,“半个月”不是half a month,而是two weeks或a fortnight;“半年”不是half a year,而是six months,但“一年半”可以说a year and a half或eighteen months.2 F0 @: `0 p2 T# k i9 W1 y
用crowded来修饰traffic大有人在
; w& F3 W% A8 ^8 t% q我们是否经常自己写或听到别人说这样的英语:
( W' n" C: C* o8 q, M# Y9 BI’m sure she’ll be late for class because of the crowded traffic.又譬如:Traffic in Beijing is too crowded.但是traffic跟crowded是联系不上的。Traffic是the coming and going of vehicles and people(车辆和行人的来往),而crowded是某场所挤满人或东西的拥挤,或事情安排得紧紧的。可以说:The small room is crowded with broken chairs and desks. (小屋子里堆满了破损的桌椅。) I had a crowded week last month. (上个月有一个星期我极忙。) More people are trying to get into the crowded hall.(还有人想方设法进入人满为患的大厅)
2 f2 h& p2 V# C中国话里“交通拥挤”的概念是“街上挤满了过往的车辆和行人”。因此,可以说:The streets are crowded with vehicles and people.显而易见,不能说:There is little traffic at this hour. Even the traffic policeman is nowhere to be found.(这会儿几乎没有过往车辆,连交通警也不见了。)
( _$ {' N5 F! y; N# C“你真熊!”是“You bear!”吗?, P& h2 K7 B/ d* Y j H1 A
我听到有人说“You bear! You even didn’t mention it!”(你真熊,你竟然没有提起它!)% I) R$ b" q! M. }/ T9 d$ T% S
汉语里可以用“熊”来表示“懦夫”、“胆小鬼”,但要是说You bear!肯定native speakers不明白。在英语中,尽管熊可以认为是凶猛、危险、笨拙之物,但却没有“怯懦”的意思;chicken倒是有“怯懦”的含意。把You bear改为You chicken就成了地道的英语了。如果有人对你说Don’t be a chicken,你就会明白他是说Don’t be afraid,他在鼓励你。 |
|